BuchananAmericanRestaurant

Fat Sal’s Bar & Grill in Buchanan: Cloth Napkins for a Plate of Wings

The name Fat Sal’s had me picturing stale beer and peanut shells on the floor (not that there’s anything wrong with that). I sat at the bar on a Sunday before the games started, and it turned out to be date night material.

Recommendation: Get the Thai chili wings at the bar, then come back for date night.

The stone front of Fat Sal’s Bar & Grill on Tate Avenue in Buchanan, with a black awning, blue umbrellas over the sidewalk patio and Fat Sal’s Bar & Grill banners on the railings
Fat Sal’s Bar & Grill on Tate Avenue in Buchanan

Fat Sal’s presents as a mid to high end restaurant with a good bar. The menu has the bar favorites, wings, nachos and $20 burgers, right next to a 24 ounce dry aged USDA prime ribeye for $68 and a cold seafood cocktail for two at $58. I got a cloth napkin and a wooden placemat at the bar for a plate of wings.

A place setting at the bar at Fat Sal’s Bar & Grill, a wooden tile placemat with a cloth napkin, fork and knife, and a pint of Sam Adams Octoberfest
A cloth napkin and a wooden placemat at the bar

Fat Sal’s opened in September 2014. The Examiner News reported at the time that the name refers to the cow on the sign and to partner Sal Barone, who owns Augie’s Prime Cut in Mohegan Lake. Fat Sal’s was meant to be the more casual of the two.

The wings

I ordered 10 Thai chili wings for $16. They’re big and meaty, and the skin stayed moderately crisp under the glaze. The sauce is sweet with mild heat, maybe mild to medium for some. I wasn’t expecting hot, so it was fine. Very tasty! The blue cheese is thick, and they come with carrot and celery sticks. If you want them hot, the Buffalo Hot wings at Fulgum’s Bar & Grill in Montrose are definitely on the hot side, and ten are $15.

Ten Thai chili wings at Fat Sal’s Bar & Grill on a white plate with carrot and celery sticks and a cup of blue cheese, a pint of Sam Adams Octoberfest behind them
10 Thai chili wings, $16

I grade “B+” for the Thai chili wings. Ten for $16 is $1.60 a wing, and the Westchester Wing Index has what a regular order costs around the county. The other sauces are buffalo mild or hot, Sal’s Way, barbecue, teriyaki and garlic, and you can get 20 for $30 or 30 for $45.

The bar

The bar has a stainless steel top and a wood back bar with glass sconces and a garland of white flowers. Albios was my bartender, and the service was excellent. “A” for service.

The bar at Fat Sal’s Bar & Grill, a stainless steel top with a pint of beer on a coaster and a menu, and a wood back bar with glass sconces, a garland of white flowers and an NFL pregame show on the TV
The bar at Fat Sal’s

I had two Sam Adams Octoberfests at $8 each (they rang up as Sam Adams Seasonal). There are about 20 taps with a regional craft lean: Sloop Juice Bomb, Captain Lawrence Freshchester, Equilibrium MC2, Fiddlehead IPA, Von Trapp Pilsner and Maine Beer Lunch, plus the usual Bud Light and Michelob Ultra.

About 20 tap handles at Fat Sal’s Bar & Grill, including Michelob Ultra, Bud Light, Fiddlehead, Fat Tire, Stella Artois, Modelo, Mango Cart, Captain Lawrence Freshchester, Sloop Juice Bomb, Lagunitas IPA, Yuengling, Samuel Adams Octoberfest and Guinness
About 20 taps

Two guys at the bar ordered espresso martinis and steak salads, and they praised both. The martinis were shaken and fine strained into coupes.

The bartender at Fat Sal’s Bar & Grill pouring an espresso martini from a shaker through a fine strainer into a frosted stem coupe
Espresso martinis, fine strained into coupes

It was quiet at the bar, with light jazz and Norah Jones in the background. There are TVs at the bar and one in the dining room, and the NFL pregame was on, but Fat Sal’s is not a sports bar destination.

Happy hour

Happy hour is Monday to Friday, 4 to 7pm at the bar. The card says it also runs during NFL games and the Super Bowl, but not on national holidays. Appetizers are $10, including eight wings. Mixed drinks, martinis, mojitos, margaritas and house wines are $8. Budweiser, Bud Light, Coors Light, Michelob Ultra and Yuengling are $4.

I checked out at 12:02pm, before kickoff, so I paid full price. On a Sunday, go after the games start. There are more deals on the Westchester happy hour list.

The Fat Sal’s happy hour card: Monday to Friday, 4 to 7pm at the bar, also during NFL games and the Super Bowl, $10 appetizers including 8 wings, $8 drinks and $4 Budweiser, Bud Light, Coors Light, Michelob Ultra and Yuengling
Happy hour at Fat Sal’s

The room

The stone front building reads more neighborhood restaurant than bar. There’s a sidewalk patio out front and a side patio, both under blue umbrellas with bistro chairs.

Inside, the main room has high tops and plaid banquettes. A back dining room holds about ten more tables, with plank floors, sconces and a wall of glazed bowls. Three or four tables were filled at noon on a Sunday. “A-” for ambiance.

The main room at Fat Sal’s Bar & Grill, high top tables and wood chairs on a plank floor, plaid banquettes along the walls, framed horse paintings and wall sconces
The main room at Fat Sal’s
The side patio at Fat Sal’s Bar & Grill, black and white woven bistro chairs at tables set with napkins under blue umbrellas
The back dining room at Fat Sal’s Bar & Grill, about ten tables on a wide plank floor with plaid banquettes, a wall of glazed bowls and sconces

The bathroom was very clean. “A” for cleanliness.

Parking is free, across the street and behind the building. My tab was $34.68 with tax for the wings and two beers.

The menu

Entrees run from $26 for the chicken dishes to $68 for the ribeye, and the specials included filet mignon medallions at $48 and lobster ravioli at $38. Weekday lunch is Monday to Friday, 11am to 4pm, and most plates are $20.

The Fat Sal’s menu of starters, salads, wings, soup and burgers, with wings at $16 for 10, $30 for 20 and $45 for 30, nachos at $13 and 10 ounce burgers at $20
The Fat Sal’s menu of entrees, pasta, sides and weekday lunch, with a dry aged 24 ounce USDA prime ribeye at $68, a 20 ounce Berkshire pork chop at $42 and most lunch plates at $20
The Fat Sal’s specials menu, with a cold seafood cocktail for two at $58, lobster ravioli at $38, filet mignon medallions at $48 and a dry aged prime ribeye at $68
The Fat Sal’s drink list, with draft beers including Juice Bomb IPA, Fiddlehead IPA, Equilibrium MC2, Lunch IPA and Captain Lawrence Pale Ale, plus martinis, mojitos, margaritas and frozen drinks

Weekend brunch is Saturday and Sunday, 11am to 3pm, with a mimosa, Bellini, sangria or Bloody Mary for $10. The kids menu is for 10 and under, dine in only, at $12 to $18.

The Fat Sal’s a la carte brunch menu, Saturday and Sunday 11am to 3pm, with a mimosa, Bellini, sangria or Bloody Mary at $10 and most plates at $18, plus a $16 kids brunch
The Fat Sal’s kids menu, 10 and under, dine in only, from $12 for chicken fingers with fries to $18 for shrimp parmigiana
The Fat Sal’s dessert and cordials card, with chocolate lava cake, cheesecake, tartufo and an espresso martini among the cordials
Dessert and cordials

Somebody at Fat Sal’s must really love the Risotto Alba, because it’s on the pasta menu twice, same price, same description. The drink list has a Downeast “Unfitered” cider, and the specials offer filet mignon “Medalions.” None of it has any bearing on the review.

Their website has the menus, but some of the other information there looks out of date, so check anything that matters to you before you go. The beer list still names Bull & Barrel, Goose Island and Dogfish Head 60 Minute, none of which I saw on the taps. It also lists $8 nightly specials, from Mojito Monday to Ladies’ Night on Thursday, that weren’t on the table cards. And the map on the site points to 256 Tate Ave. Fat Sal’s is at 265.

Next time

I haven’t had a real meal here yet. I’m definitely coming back for date night, and I’ll order from the upscale side to see if the food matches the ambiance and the service. For a big dinner nearby in the meantime, Table 9 in Cortlandt Manor has heavy portions and a deep menu.

Frequently asked questions about Fat Sal’s Bar & Grill

Is Fat Sal’s in Buchanan a dive bar?
No. Despite the name, it’s a mid to high end restaurant with a good bar: cloth napkins, a quiet room with light jazz, and a menu that runs from wings and burgers to a $68 dry aged prime ribeye.
Does Fat Sal’s have happy hour during football games?
Yes. Happy hour is Monday to Friday, 4 to 7pm at the bar, and the table card says it also runs during NFL games and the Super Bowl, but not on national holidays. Appetizers are $10, drinks $8 and domestic beers $4.
How much are the wings at Fat Sal’s?
$16 for 10, $30 for 20 and $45 for 30. Sauces include buffalo mild or hot, Sal’s Way, barbecue, teriyaki, Thai chili and garlic. Eight wings are $10 at happy hour.
Are the Thai chili wings at Fat Sal’s spicy?
Not very. They’re sweet with mild heat, maybe mild to medium for some. The wings are big and meaty, and the skin stays moderately crisp under the glaze.
What beer does Fat Sal’s have on tap?
About 20 drafts with a regional craft lean, including Sloop Juice Bomb, Captain Lawrence Freshchester, Equilibrium MC2, Fiddlehead IPA, Von Trapp Pilsner and Maine Beer Lunch, plus Bud Light, Michelob Ultra and Yuengling.
Is Fat Sal’s good for a date night?
Yes. The room is quiet, with light jazz in the background, plus a back dining room of about ten tables and an upscale side of the menu with steaks and seafood.
Does Fat Sal’s have outdoor seating?
Yes. There’s a sidewalk patio out front and a side patio, both with umbrellas.
Is there parking at Fat Sal’s?
Yes, free parking across the street and behind the building.
Does Fat Sal’s serve brunch?
Yes, Saturday and Sunday from 11am to 3pm. A mimosa, Bellini, sangria or Bloody Mary is $10, and there’s a $16 kids brunch for 10 and under.
What are the hours at Fat Sal’s Bar & Grill?
11am to 10pm Sunday to Thursday, and 11am to 11pm Friday and Saturday, per their website as of October 2026. Parts of the website look out of date, so call (914) 930-1770 if it matters.
Pros
Big, meaty Thai chili wings Excellent service at the bar A quiet room with cloth napkins, good for date night About 20 taps with regional craft beer Happy hour during NFL games Two patios Free parking Very clean bathroom
Cons
The Thai chili wings are mild, if you want heat Not a sports bar destination
Fat Sal’s Bar & Grill
265 Tate Ave, Buchanan, NY 10511
Phone: (914) 930-1770
Hours, as of October 4, 2026, per their website:
Sunday to Thursday 11am to 10pm
Friday and Saturday 11am to 11pm
Website: fatsalsbarandgrill.com

More reviews near Buchanan

Don't judge this book by it's cover

Drinks
Food
Cost/Value
Atmosphere
Service
Cleanliness

User Rating: Be the first one !

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Back to top button