Cortlandt ManorAmericanCityRestaurant

Table 9 in Cortlandt Manor: Heavy Portions, a Deep Menu, and a $13 Large Beer

Unexpectedly good!

I walked in expecting a nice diner, and it is a level above that, which is not what I predicted from the outside.

Recommendation: Order the Meatloaf Stack.

The Table 9 sign and entrance on Roa Hook Road at Annsville Circle in Cortlandt Manor, seen from the parking lot at dusk
It is right on the Annsville Circle and impossible to miss.

I’ve gone around the Annsville Circle dozens of times in the last couple of years. Route 9 meets 6 meets 202 there, everybody in the north end of the county passes through it, and Table 9 sits right on the corner with a lit sign and a big metal 9 on the roof. Every single time I thought about stopping. Every single time I kept driving.

Friday night my wife and I were free and had no plan. We pulled the menu up on a phone, read it for about four minutes, and drove over. Parking is free and plentiful.

The bar

We sat at the bar for a drink and an appetizer while we decided whether to move to a table for dinner. We never moved. Two bartenders were working, both quick, both friendly, and there was no reason to get up.

The bar at Table 9 in Cortlandt Manor, a granite bar top, two draft towers, glassware racks overhead and a bartender working the register
Granite bar top, two towers, glassware overhead. We sat down for one drink and stayed for dinner.

The draft list is not bad at all… Captain Lawrence Pale Ale and Commander IPA, Lagunitas, Goose Island, Newburgh Mega Boss, Blue Moon, Stella, Peroni, Yuengling, Guinness, a Sam Adams seasonal, Shock Top, Coors Light. Everything comes in two sizes, 16 ounces or 22, and the printed prices run $6 to $8 for the small one and $8 to $10 for the big one.

Draft handles at the Table 9 bar including Captain Lawrence, Lagunitas, Goose Island, Newburgh Mega Boss, Stella Artois, Peroni and Shock Top
A dozen handles and change. The one I ordered was not among them.

Then there’s the rotating tap, and that’s where it got me.

I had two 22 ounce pours of Wrench, the hazy IPA that Industrial Arts brews up in Beacon. Very good beer. It’s 7.1%, BeerAdvocate has it scored at 95, “World Class.”  It also cost $13 a pour for the large. That’s three dollars over anything printed on the menu, and I didn’t learn it until the check came. So ask what the rotating tap costs before you order it. 

A 22 ounce pour of Industrial Arts Wrench IPA on the bar at Table 9, hazy gold with a thick white head
Twenty two ounces of Wrench. Worth drinking, worth asking the price of first.

My wife had a glass of Cupcake Moscato, $10, and was a big fan.

The Table 9 drink menu listing draft beer in 16 and 22 ounce pours from $6 to $10, wine by the glass from $9 to $12, and happy hour Monday to Friday 4pm to 6pm
The printed beer and wine list. Drafts in two sizes, wine by the glass $9 to $12, happy hour 4 to 6 on weekdays in the bar and lounge.

The calamari

Seventeen dollars, and worth it,.

Most places you’d file under average serve calamari with the texture of a pencil eraser. This  was tender the whole way through, and the breading came off in my fingers when I picked a piece up. That’s the tell. Frozen calamari doesn’t shed its coating like that, so somebody back there is breading it that afternoon. I’d put the quality well above any average restaurant.

The $17 crispy calamari at Table 9, rings only with no tentacles, served in a wire basket with lemon wedges and a ramekin of marinara
Tender, not rubbery, and the breading gives up the second you touch it. That is a good sign.

One odd thing: not a single tentacle in the basket. All rings. I’m ok with or without the tentacles but I noticed there weren’t any.

The fresh warm bread showed up without being asked for and without appearing on the check. 

The complimentary bread basket at Table 9, a sliced crusty loaf dusted with flour in a wire basket lined with parchment

 

The Table 9 appetizer menu listing crispy calamari at $17, buffalo wings at $17, T-9 mussels at $18 and the T-9 sampler at $28
Appetizers. The calamari is $17 and the wings are the same, which we will come back to.

The rooms

It’s a much bigger building than it reads from the circle. There are tables out in the bar area, and behind that a full dining room that has to seat well over a hundred. It was busy on a Friday night. It also wasn’t loud, and that surprised me enough that I walked back to look at it properly, because a full room that size normally roars. High ceilings, soft chairs, a lot of broken up surfaces. Whatever the reason, you can hold a conversation in there at a normal volume.

The main dining room at Table 9 on a busy Friday night, olive leather chairs and booths under big square pendant lanterns cut with the number nine
Full on a Friday night and still quiet enough to talk. That is harder to pull off than it looks.

The bathroom was genuinely clean. 5 stars for cleanliness here.

There’s also a separate banquet room off the back. Round tables, chiavari chairs, mirrors down one wall, a podium, and a hardwood dance floor. Their site puts it at 60 to 125 people with prix fixe packages. If you’ve got a christening or a retirement or a milestone birthday coming and you don’t want a huge hotel catering hall, Table 9 has got you covered.

The banquet room at Table 9 set for a party, round tables with white linens and blue napkins beside a hardwood dance floor
Round tables and silver chiavari chairs set with blue napkins and floral centerpieces in the Table 9 banquet room

Dinner

The Meatloaf Stack is $22 and it’s outstanding. Two thick slabs layered with melted cheese and caramelized onions, wild mushroom gravy over the top, garlic mashed with the red skins left in, and a vegetable medley that got cooked rather than steamed into submission. I don’t normally take food home. I took half of this home.

The $22 Meatloaf Stack at Table 9, two slabs of meatloaf layered with melted cheese and caramelized onions under mushroom gravy, with garlic mashed potatoes and a vegetable medley
The $22 Meatloaf Stack

My wife had the lemon chicken piccata, $24, chicken breasts over angel hair in a lemon butter sauce. She was really happy with it, and she took half of hers home too. Portions here are heavy across the board. A+

The $24 lemon chicken piccata at Table 9, sauteed chicken breasts in lemon butter sauce over angel hair pasta with a lemon wheel
Lemon chicken piccata, $24. We’ll make two meals out of it.

The menu, and what it costs

The menu is deep. Not deep for a bar, deep the way a good diner is deep, and there’s a moment flipping through it where that’s exactly what you think you’re holding. Then the food arrives and you aren’t. Burgers are nine ounces and ground in house, $16 to $19. Steaks run from a $29 New York strip to a $38 Delmonico at twenty ounces, with a twelve ounce prime rib at $32 that only exists Friday and Saturday from 4 and Sunday from 1, until they run out. There’s a lobster roll at $29. There’s a turkey club at $17.

The Table 9 signature dishes menu listing the Meatloaf Stack at $22, lemon chicken piccata at $24, parmesan crusted chicken at $25 and burgers from $16 to $19
The Table 9 specialties menu listing steaks from $29 to $38, seafood from $25 to $29, and 12 ounce prime rib at $32 on Friday, Saturday and Sunday
The Table 9 menu listing big gourmet salads from $14 to $21 with lunch portions, and sandwiches from $15 to $29 including a $29 lobster roll
Salads and sandwiches. Lunch portions on the salads until 4, and a $29 lobster roll if you are feeling it.

The wings are the one thing I’d push on. They’re $17 on the appetizer page, and when I asked how many come in an order the answer was “eight or nine.” Eight or nine. Call it two dollars a wing at the wrong end of that count, which drops Table 9 in with the rest of the county on what wings now cost in Westchester. Everything else on this menu is priced like somebody thought about it. The wings are priced like everybody else.

Here’s the number that actually matters. Early dinner is $19 for soup or salad, an entree, and a soft drink or an iced tea, Monday through Friday from 3:00 to 5:45, parties of nine or under. The Meatloaf Stack is on that list. So are the fish and chips, the marinated pork chops, the chicken marsala and the chop house burger. House wine is $7 while it runs. We sat down at about 6:35 and missed it by fifty minutes, and now that I know what the kitchen does, I’d move dinner up an hour to catch it.

The Table 9 early dinner menu, $19 for soup or salad plus an entree plus a soft drink, served Monday to Friday 3pm to 5:45pm, with the Meatloaf Stack among the choices
The $19 early dinner. Soup or salad, an entree off this list, and a drink, weekdays until 5:45.

Happy hour is 4 to 6 Monday through Friday, bar and lounge only. Sunday brunch runs 11 to 3, with ninety minutes of unlimited brunch cocktails for $23 if that’s your Sunday.

The Table 9 Sunday brunch menu, served 11am to 3pm, alongside the specialty cocktail list, with unlimited brunch cocktails for 90 minutes at $23
The Table 9 dessert menu listing house made desserts from $7 to $9 and a Really BIG Hot Fudge Sundae that serves 11 at $29

One more thing, and it’s printed right on the cover of the menu: no separate checks. “The time saved will be used to better serve you and other guests.” Sort out who’s paying before you walk in with a group of eight.

The cover of the Table 9 menu, printed with the address, the phone number and a line reading No separate checks
No separate checks, in print, on the cover. They are not hiding it.

The tab

Calamari $17, chicken piccata $24, Meatloaf Stack $22, the Moscato $10, two Wrench at $26. Ninety nine dollars flat before tax, $107.29 after it. That’s two people eating and drinking well on a Friday night with half of both entrees going home in boxes, and for what came out of that kitchen it’s a fair number. Competitive, even, against places up here doing less.

The Table 9 receipt showing calamari $17, chicken piccata $24, Meatloaf Stack $22, a glass of Cupcake Moscato $10 and two 22 ounce Wrench IPAs at $26, a $99 subtotal and $107.29 with tax
Ninety nine before tax, $107.29 after. Note the $26 line for two beers.

We’ll be back. What I keep chewing on is that I drove past this place for two years because I thought I already knew what it was from the outside, and I was wrong about it in the direction nobody is ever wrong in. If you want the other Cortlandt Manor rooms, AJ’s Bar and Grill and the Back Nine aren’t too far, and both are doing something completely different than this. Over in Buchanan, Fat Sal’s Bar & Grill sounds like a dive and turned out to be date night material.

Frequently asked questions about Table 9

Where is Table 9?
92 Roa Hook Road in Cortlandt Manor, NY 10567, right on Route 9 at the Annsville Circle. The number is (914) 737-4959. Parking is free and there is plenty of it.
What is good to eat at Table 9?
The Meatloaf Stack, $22. Two slabs layered with cheese and caramelized onions under wild mushroom gravy, with garlic mashed and vegetables, and it beat both of us. The $17 crispy calamari is tender rather than rubbery, which is rarer than it should be.
Does Table 9 have an early dinner special?
Yes, and it is the best value in the building. $19 gets you soup or salad, an entree and a soft drink or iced tea, Monday to Friday from 3:00 to 5:45 pm, parties of nine or under. The Meatloaf Stack is one of the choices and house wine is $7.
How much is a beer at Table 9?
Drafts pour in 16 and 22 ounce sizes, roughly $6 to $8 for the small and $8 to $10 for the large. The rotating tap is priced on its own: my 22 ounce Wrench was $13. Ask what it costs before you order it.
Does Table 9 have a party room?
Yes, a separate banquet room at the back with round tables and a hardwood dance floor. Their site puts it at 60 to 125 guests with prix fixe packages. It is a proper event space, not a roped off corner of the dining room.
Is Table 9 loud?
No. The dining room was full on a Friday night and we could still talk without raising our voices. I went and looked at the room because I did not believe it from the bar.
How much are wings at Table 9?
$17, and when I asked how many come in an order the bartender said eight or nine. That works out near two dollars a wing, which is steep even by current Westchester standards.
Does Table 9 serve brunch?
Sunday brunch runs 11 am to 3 pm. Ninety minutes of unlimited brunch cocktails is $23 on top of the food.
Does Table 9 split checks?
No, and it says so on the cover of the menu. Their line is that the time saved goes into serving you and everyone else faster. Work out who is paying before you sit down with a group.
What did dinner cost at Table 9?
Two entrees, an appetizer, a glass of wine and two 22 ounce beers came to $99 before tax and $107.29 after. We took half of both dinners home, so call it two meals each.

Pros

Meatloaf Stack at $22, and portions big enough to take half home
Calamari that is actually tender, breaded in house
Early dinner at $19 including soup or salad and a drink, weekdays to 5:45
A big dining room that stays quiet when it is full
Free parking, and plenty of it
Banquet room with a real dance floor, 60 to 125 people
Bread comes free and nobody makes you ask

Cons

The rotating tap is $13 for 22 ounces and the price is nowhere in print
$17 for eight or nine wings
No separate checks, ever
No tentacles in the calamari
Table 9
92 Roa Hook Road, Cortlandt Manor, NY 10567
Phone: (914) 737-4959
Hours, as of September 27, 2026, per their website:
Monday to Thursday 11:30am to 9pm
Friday and Saturday 11:30am to 10pm
Sunday 11am to 9pm
Website: Table 9
Instagram: @t9fooddrink

More reviews near Cortlandt Manor

All Cortlandt Manor reviews

Drinks
Food
Cost/Value
Atmosphere
Service
Cleanliness

User Rating: Be the first one !

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Back to top button